RLS: Should Art that Infuriates Be Removed?

https://www.nytimes.com/2017/03/27/arts/design/emmett-till-whitney-biennial-schutz.html

The article delves into the debate surrounding Dana Schutz's painting "Open Casket", displayed at the White Biennial. Controversially, the painting is about Emmet Till, an African American 14 year old who was mutilated by two white men for flirting with a white store clerk. In the painting, he is painted in his coffin, the focal point being his mutilated face. However, the reason why this painting is being protested to be taken down is that it was painted by Schutz, who is ethnically white. The African-American community believes that he has no ethnic ownership of the genre, and that therefore, he is appropriating it to an extent that the deeper meaning of Till's event is being completely overlooked.

The following questions ensue:

-To what extent should intent influence interpretation? Which interpretation should be deemed correct?
-To what extent should a social group have ownership of artistic images and genres?

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Somatic Marker Theory

Image
The Somatic Marker Theory is a physiological hypothesis proposed by Antonion Damasio. He suggests that every experience we face stores what is called a somatic marker, which is kept in our memories. As a result, our body remembers how it reacted to specific scenarios and based upon both the emotions and physiological reactions to the aforesaid, it impacts our decision-making. This hypothesis is particularly true in situations in which our cognition and logic can not make a decision, and therefore, we rely on our emotions to reach make a choice. Damasio believes that emotions are physiological stimuli that occur when we are exposed to different situations. Those physiological stimuli are processed by the brain, which the brain then turns into an emotion that tells the individual how they should feel in response to those stimuli.  An example (as shown in the picture) can be food. When you eat really good chocolate cake, your physiological response comes from a mix of you...
Read more

Real Life Situation: "Are 'emoji' dumbing us down or enriching our communities?

First-Order Knowledge Claims -"Ghost balloon may have no intrinsic meaning" -"But as a whole, emoji are unmistakably Japanese" -"Purchases that reportedly rake in well over $3m each month" Second-Order Knowledge Claims -The fact that 'ghost balloon' may have no intrinsic meaning is based on a generalized assumption that that specific combination of emojis don't have a translation into verbal language, and therefore, have no deep-rooted meaning. (this leaves out the fact that those symbols could have inherent meaning in the form of an inside-joke to a specific group of people) -The knowledge that the emojis are Japanese is based on the shared knowledge of Japanese culture and the cultural traits (food, clothes, etc) that are associated with it. Knowledge Questions -To what extent can the simplification of language in a visual form continue to be valuable for communication?/ Can visual communication ever be as rich and communicative as...
Read more

A New Way to look at emotions

Lisa Feldman Barret's theory of how we perceive emotion comes through as highly-thought provoking, and to an extent, is implying a potential paradigm shift in how we understand what emotions are in their very essence. One of the first points presented is the idea that physiological stimuli can be used interchangeably to tell our body different emotions. However, the way those same stimuli are used to distinguish emotions rely on the context itself. What this puts into question is the true reliability of our emotions. If it comes to a point where the body is trying to express a feeling but the context does not lend itself to the interpretation what the body wants to achieve, this can lead to flawed decision-making. This puts into perspective how it is crucial to comprehend the possible unreliability of emotions– if the wrong context happens to coincide with the wrong physiological stimuli, the decision-making that is born from that union can have dangerous ramifications. This exa...
Read more